I have been viewing the forums here for awhile, and came across this thread. Decided this was as good an issue as any to make a first post on.

As we all know there are multiple formulas for calculating the weight of a bass based on length and/or girth. Matt, I am curious which formula you are using to get the estimate you give for the Perry bass. I have seen the 25+ weight given from a few formulas I have run using the 32.5 inches x 28.5 inches (I have also gotten estimates lower and closer to the size listed for Perry's bass). On these formulas I have not been able to get either of the other two bass you reference to come in anywhere near their actual weight, both were much lower.

By no means am I questioning those weights or sizes, just that the formulas used are inexact sciences. If you would let me know what formula you are using, I would be glad to compare those with formulas that are most commonly used for Florida bass.

Without knowing how you reach your conclusions, I will refrain from discussing any of the assertions of Perry's bass being a hoax. Look forward to hearing from you.