Facebook YouTube Tacklewarehouse.com
Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Top Calfishing.com Saltwater Fishing in California topic #9617
View in linear mode

Subject: "RE: Fish feel pain & barbless hooks in the surf?" Previous topic | Next topic
brianWed Apr-30-03 02:51 PM
Charter member
2409 posts
Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy listClick to send message via AOL IM
#9623, "RE: Fish feel pain & barbless hooks in the surf?"
In response to In response to 5


  

          

Ok, listen here sonny.

I think you gotta define pain first of all. I'm defining it as the human characteristic of disabling discomfort, I think we all know the feeling of pain, so I won't explain it in depth. Fish do not have the neurological system, or the brain power to experience pain like we do. Not even a fraction of it. I do think that fish know when something isn't right, or something is happening that's going to prevent them from functioning (eating, reproducing, keep living...) and that's what they're reacting to. People like PETA, and extreme radical environmentalists like rob want to use the word 'pain', but it doesn't apply. People and fish have two COMPLETELY different anatomies, brain functions, nerve systems, chemical balances, etc etc. Fish probably experience feelings that we don't even have words for. The closest thing to pain that fish are able to comprehend is that something is imminently wrong and needs to be fixed asap so that they can go back to eating and reproducing.
-Brian

  

Alert Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote

Fish feel pain & barbless hooks in the surf? [View all] , dball, Wed Apr-30-03 12:42 PM
  RE: Fish feel pain & barbless hooks in the surf?, Hawgsticker, Apr 30th 2003, #1
RE: Fish feel pain & barbless hooks in the surf?, brian, Apr 30th 2003, #2
      RE: Fish feel pain & barbless hooks in the surf?, swimbait, Apr 30th 2003, #3
           RE: Fish feel pain & barbless hooks in the surf?, brian, Apr 30th 2003, #4
                RE: Fish feel pain & barbless hooks in the surf?, swimbait, Apr 30th 2003, #5
                RE: Fish feel pain & barbless hooks in the surf?, brian, Apr 30th 2003 #6
                     RE: Fish feel pain & barbless hooks in the surf?, swimbait, Apr 30th 2003, #7
                          RE: Fish feel pain & barbless hooks in the surf?, brian, Apr 30th 2003, #8
                          RE: Fish feel pain & barbless hooks in the surf?, swimbait, Apr 30th 2003, #9
                               RE: Fish feel pain & barbless hooks in the surf?, swimbait, Apr 30th 2003, #10
                                    RE: Fish feel pain & barbless hooks in the surf?, brian, Apr 30th 2003, #11
                          RE: Fish feel pain & barbless hooks in the surf?, Grom85, Apr 30th 2003, #12
                RE: Fish feel pain & barbless hooks in the surf?, salmonoid 1, Apr 30th 2003, #13
                     RE: Fish feel pain & barbless hooks in the surf?, dball, Apr 30th 2003, #14
                          RE: Fish feel pain & barbless hooks in the surf?, salmonoid 1, May 01st 2003, #16
                               RE: Fish feel pain & barbless hooks in the surf?, Wade, May 01st 2003, #17
RE: Fish feel pain & barbless hooks in the surf?, Riffly, May 01st 2003, #15
RE: Fish feel pain & barbless hooks in the surf?, onelove4u, May 11th 2003, #18

Top Calfishing.com Saltwater Fishing in California topic #9617 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+
© Copyright Robert Belloni 1997-2012. All Rights Reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without express written consent.