I have fished the lobster. It is probably the biggest most bulky soft plastic bait I have fished. I fished it one night last year, and I had several bites. I know I caught one fish in the 6lb range. I can't remember if I caught anymore. I think it is a good bait, but I do not think it is any better than the double wide sweet beavers I usually fish. If they were priced better, I would definately fish them more. If I remember correct, it is only like 2 baits per pack, and each pack is about the same price as the double wide beavers. So, I choose the beavers over the lobsters.